Now Open in Lancaster

Lancaster, your daily cup of happiness is waiting right here.

From our oven to your hands — artisan breads, fresh pastries, and carefully crafted coffee in a space that feels like home. We're more than a café; we're your neighborhood gathering spot on Broadway.

Explore Our Menu Find Us
6090
Broadway
14086
Lancaster, NY
Daily
Fresh Baked
Warm coffee house interior with fresh pastries and coffee
Made with Love
Every single day
Fresh artisan bread from The Stirring
Latte art at The Stirring Coffee House
Cozy interior of The Stirring Coffee House
Fresh pastries on display
Our Story

Baking memories since day one on Broadway

The Stirring Coffee House was born from a simple belief: that the best moments happen over good food and great coffee. Located right here in Lancaster, we've been serving our neighbors with freshly baked goods and warm hospitality ever since.

Every loaf, every pastry, and every cup is prepared with care using quality ingredients. We source locally whenever we can, support fellow Lancaster businesses, and pour our hearts into everything we make. This isn't just a bakery — it's a place where regulars become friends.

Fresh Daily

Baked every morning with love

Locally Sourced

Supporting Lancaster farmers

Our Community

More than a café — we're your neighbors

The Stirring Coffee House was built for Lancaster. We're proud to be part of this vibrant community, and we love being a place where people gather, connect, and create memories.

Whether you're grabbing a quick coffee on your way to work, meeting friends for brunch, or picking up fresh bread for dinner, we're here to make your day a little brighter. Our doors are always open, our coffee is always fresh, and our welcome is always warm.

A Warm Atmosphere

Rounded corners, soft lighting, and cozy seating make our space feel inviting for everyone.

Community Focused

We partner with local suppliers and support Lancaster events and organizations.

Locally Sourced

We work with Lancaster-area farms and producers to bring you the freshest ingredients.

Community gathering at The Stirring Coffee House
Lancaster Locals

"My favorite spot in town. The coffee is perfect and the bread is always fresh!"

Visit Us

Come say hello

We're located right on Broadway in Lancaster. Pull up a chair, grab a cup, and stay a while.

Find Us

Address

6090 Broadway
Lancaster, NY 14086-9511

Hours

Monday - Friday 6:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Saturday 7:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Sunday 7:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Get in Touch

We'd love to hear from you

Have a question, want to place an order, or just want to say hi? Drop us a line and we'll get back to you as soon as we can.

6090 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086-9511
(171) 626-7216
michele.messina14@yahoo.com
Is this your business?This is my business